{
  "measured": "2026-07-14T17:32:50",
  "instrument": "the commit-email TOLERANCE PANEL — buildTriptychInputs (ballistic walk on the FULL reef-144) → renderTriptych decodeDeltaThreeColourEdges @ 15% kill tolerance",
  "specMode": "generic",
  "spec": "GENERIC — FULL Strategy region of reef-144 (every A-family cell seed, 48 cells) — full spec, full reef, no toy (6771 chars)",
  "question": "does in-universe (Strategy) work stay IN tolerance and out-of-universe work BREACH it — blind, corpus scale",
  "N": {
    "in": 10,
    "out": 10,
    "paraphrases": 10
  },
  "tolerance": {
    "in_region_in_tolerance": {
      "held": 8,
      "of": 10,
      "rate": 0.8
    },
    "out_region_breaches": {
      "breach": 10,
      "of": 10,
      "rate": 1
    },
    "accuracy": 0.9
  },
  "paraphrase_invariance": {
    "held": 3,
    "of": 10,
    "rate": 0.3
  },
  "gates": {
    "separates": true,
    "in_region_holds": true,
    "out_region_breaches": true,
    "paraphrase_invariant": false,
    "better_than_chance": true
  },
  "rows": [
    {
      "id": "in-001",
      "label": "in",
      "offPct": 0,
      "tooMany": false,
      "region": "INSURABLE/none",
      "inTolerance": true,
      "paraOffPct": 30,
      "paraInTolerance": false
    },
    {
      "id": "out-002",
      "label": "out",
      "offPct": 29,
      "tooMany": true,
      "region": "PRICEABLE/horizontal",
      "inTolerance": false,
      "paraOffPct": null,
      "paraInTolerance": null
    },
    {
      "id": "in-003",
      "label": "in",
      "offPct": 0,
      "tooMany": false,
      "region": "INSURABLE/none",
      "inTolerance": true,
      "paraOffPct": 29,
      "paraInTolerance": false
    },
    {
      "id": "out-004",
      "label": "out",
      "offPct": 17,
      "tooMany": true,
      "region": "UNINSURABLE/horizontal",
      "inTolerance": false,
      "paraOffPct": null,
      "paraInTolerance": null
    },
    {
      "id": "in-005",
      "label": "in",
      "offPct": 0,
      "tooMany": false,
      "region": "INSURABLE/none",
      "inTolerance": true,
      "paraOffPct": 0,
      "paraInTolerance": true
    },
    {
      "id": "out-006",
      "label": "out",
      "offPct": 29,
      "tooMany": true,
      "region": "UNINSURABLE/horizontal",
      "inTolerance": false,
      "paraOffPct": null,
      "paraInTolerance": null
    },
    {
      "id": "in-007",
      "label": "in",
      "offPct": 0,
      "tooMany": false,
      "region": "INSURABLE/none",
      "inTolerance": true,
      "paraOffPct": 26,
      "paraInTolerance": false
    },
    {
      "id": "out-008",
      "label": "out",
      "offPct": 45,
      "tooMany": true,
      "region": "PRICEABLE/horizontal",
      "inTolerance": false,
      "paraOffPct": null,
      "paraInTolerance": null
    },
    {
      "id": "in-009",
      "label": "in",
      "offPct": 47,
      "tooMany": true,
      "region": "PRICEABLE/horizontal",
      "inTolerance": false,
      "paraOffPct": 38,
      "paraInTolerance": false
    },
    {
      "id": "out-010",
      "label": "out",
      "offPct": 33,
      "tooMany": true,
      "region": "UNINSURABLE/horizontal",
      "inTolerance": false,
      "paraOffPct": null,
      "paraInTolerance": null
    },
    {
      "id": "in-011",
      "label": "in",
      "offPct": 0,
      "tooMany": false,
      "region": "INSURABLE/none",
      "inTolerance": true,
      "paraOffPct": 0,
      "paraInTolerance": true
    },
    {
      "id": "out-012",
      "label": "out",
      "offPct": 30,
      "tooMany": true,
      "region": "UNINSURABLE/horizontal",
      "inTolerance": false,
      "paraOffPct": null,
      "paraInTolerance": null
    },
    {
      "id": "in-013",
      "label": "in",
      "offPct": 0,
      "tooMany": false,
      "region": "INSURABLE/none",
      "inTolerance": true,
      "paraOffPct": 35,
      "paraInTolerance": false
    },
    {
      "id": "out-014",
      "label": "out",
      "offPct": 52,
      "tooMany": true,
      "region": "PRICEABLE/horizontal",
      "inTolerance": false,
      "paraOffPct": null,
      "paraInTolerance": null
    },
    {
      "id": "in-015",
      "label": "in",
      "offPct": 29,
      "tooMany": true,
      "region": "PRICEABLE/vertical",
      "inTolerance": false,
      "paraOffPct": 31,
      "paraInTolerance": false
    },
    {
      "id": "out-016",
      "label": "out",
      "offPct": 22,
      "tooMany": true,
      "region": "PRICEABLE/horizontal",
      "inTolerance": false,
      "paraOffPct": null,
      "paraInTolerance": null
    },
    {
      "id": "in-017",
      "label": "in",
      "offPct": 0,
      "tooMany": false,
      "region": "INSURABLE/none",
      "inTolerance": true,
      "paraOffPct": 0,
      "paraInTolerance": true
    },
    {
      "id": "out-018",
      "label": "out",
      "offPct": 37,
      "tooMany": true,
      "region": "PRICEABLE/vertical",
      "inTolerance": false,
      "paraOffPct": null,
      "paraInTolerance": null
    },
    {
      "id": "in-019",
      "label": "in",
      "offPct": 0,
      "tooMany": false,
      "region": "INSURABLE/none",
      "inTolerance": true,
      "paraOffPct": 31,
      "paraInTolerance": false
    },
    {
      "id": "out-020",
      "label": "out",
      "offPct": 34,
      "tooMany": true,
      "region": "UNINSURABLE/horizontal",
      "inTolerance": false,
      "paraOffPct": null,
      "paraInTolerance": null
    }
  ],
  "VERDICT": "SEPARATES (acc 0.9) but NOT paraphrase-invariant (0.3) — out-of-universe rejection is robust (1); in-universe acceptance is partly SURFACE-bound (a reword often breaches). Semantic claim PARTIALLY supported; surface-robustness is the open inch."
}