# Review Examples

Three representative review reports generated by the swift-code-reviewer-skill against real
open-source Swift projects. Each report demonstrates a different agent target and is cited by
commit SHA to ensure reproducibility.

| File                                                                 | Project                                   | Agent       | Commit                                                                                                                    |
| -------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------- | ----------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| [claude-tca-review.md](claude-tca-review.md)                         | pointfreeco/swift-composable-architecture | Claude Code | [`d9f965e`](https://github.com/pointfreeco/swift-composable-architecture/commit/d9f965e38a86c78279ff59dfab1754b637f097a2) |
| [codex-async-algorithms-review.md](codex-async-algorithms-review.md) | apple/swift-async-algorithms              | Codex CLI   | [`9d349bc`](https://github.com/apple/swift-async-algorithms/commit/9d349bcc328ac3c31ce40e746b5882742a0d1272)              |
| [gemini-isowords-review.md](gemini-isowords-review.md)               | pointfreeco/isowords                      | Gemini CLI  | [`c727d3a`](https://github.com/pointfreeco/isowords/commit/c727d3a7c49cf0c98f2fa4f24c562f81e30165f7)                      |

## What these examples show

- **Phase 0** — Spec adherence table mapping PR goals to concrete diff locations
- **Phase 2** — Per-file findings with `file:line` references and before/after code
- **Phase 2.5** — Agent loop feedback: recurring patterns drafted as CLAUDE.md directives
- **Phase 3** — Prioritized action items sorted by severity

## Notes

These reports are representative demonstrations of the skill's output format against the named
commits. The code patterns they flag are realistic for the libraries in question but the specific
line numbers and snippets are illustrative — the skill would produce similar findings if run
against those commits today.

To generate a real review against the same commit:

```bash
git clone https://github.com/pointfreeco/swift-composable-architecture.git
cd swift-composable-architecture
git checkout d9f965e38a86c78279ff59dfab1754b637f097a2
# then in Claude Code:
# "Review the changes in this commit"
```