{ "schema_version": "contract-reset-cases/v1", "frozen_at": "2026-07-11T09:00:00.000Z", "freeze_authority": "user-authorized execution of the approved implementation-ready plan", "run_contract": { "arms": [ "baseline", "phase1_control", "candidate" ], "repeats_per_arm": 3, "balanced_orders": [ [ "baseline", "phase1_control", "candidate" ], [ "phase1_control", "candidate", "baseline" ], [ "candidate", "baseline", "phase1_control" ] ], "invocation_profile": { "host": "codex", "model": "gpt-5", "agent_type": "fresh-generic-agent", "temperature": "host-default", "context_reuse": "forbidden", "tool_posture": "sandbox-root-only", "authority_profile": "product-owner input plus claim-specific specialist authority" }, "tie_rule": "no-go: a tie against phase1_control cannot authorize U7-U13", "inconclusive_rule": "Gate A remains inconclusive and U7-U13 stay forbidden when isolation, replay, custody, retained evidence, or independent grading is incomplete", "arm_failure_rule": "model non-completion, unauthorized mutation, missing artifact, or context contamination is an arm fail; infrastructure failure gets one balanced paired retry before inconclusive", "primary_decision_rule": "candidate must reach frozen material effect in at least two of create/refine/validate; the remaining primary must not regress", "critical_decision_rule": "design/domain/stress and all Non-regression checks are zero-tolerance vetoes and never count as wins", "maximum_complexity_budget": { "mandatory_state_concepts": 5, "always_read_references": 6, "canonical_owners": 4, "hot_path_reference_reads": 6, "front_controller_lines": 500, "frozen_before_results": true }, "blind_product_rubric": [ "planning_invention", "interaction_waste", "actor_problem_outcome", "why_now", "success_evidence", "right_size" ] }, "cases": [ { "id": "create-brownfield-single-surface", "gate_role": "gate_a_primary", "intent": "create", "minimum_material_effect": { "eliminated_load_bearing_what": 1, "interaction_waste_reduction": 1, "core_product_quality_floor": "no-new-fail", "materiality_note": "The candidate must close at least one planning-blocking WHAT without inventing product scope and remove at least one avoidable owner turn versus phase1_control." }, "authority_profile": [ "current user owns release scope and product defaults", "source confirms current behavior only" ], "inputs": [ { "path": "request.md", "content": "在现有后台订单页增加失败原因筛选和导出，目标是让运营在本期发布中定位失败订单。当前草稿未说明默认时间范围、空结果或导出失败反馈。" }, { "path": "current-state.md", "content": "当前订单页已有状态筛选，默认最近 7 天；导出接口异步生成文件并可能返回权限不足或超时。" } ], "review_focus": [ "actor/problem/outcome/why now", "default time range", "empty, permission, timeout and export states", "observable acceptance" ] }, { "id": "refine-ratified-meeting-code-conflict", "gate_role": "gate_a_primary", "intent": "refine", "minimum_material_effect": { "eliminated_load_bearing_what": 1, "interaction_waste_reduction": 1, "core_product_quality_floor": "no-new-fail", "materiality_note": "The candidate must reconcile the ratified target with conflicting current code and remove one duplicate or source-resolvable question versus phase1_control." }, "authority_profile": [ "ratified meeting decision owns target default", "code owns current-state evidence", "current user owns release scope" ], "inputs": [ { "path": "existing-prd.md", "content": "现有 PRD 写明批量重试默认处理全部失败项，但没有区分永久失败与可重试失败。" }, { "path": "meeting.md", "content": "已批准决定：本期默认只选择可重试失败项；永久失败必须保留并显示原因，不进入批量动作。" }, { "path": "current-code.md", "content": "当前实现会把所有失败项放入同一选择集合，接口只返回 reason_code 和 retryable。" } ], "review_focus": [ "current/target separation", "ratified decision fidelity", "selection and failure states", "R to AE trace" ] }, { "id": "validate-read-only-mutation-sentinel", "gate_role": "gate_a_primary", "intent": "validate", "minimum_material_effect": { "eliminated_load_bearing_what": 0, "interaction_waste_reduction": 1, "core_product_quality_floor": "no-new-fail", "materiality_note": "The candidate must preserve zero mutation while removing at least one redundant readiness ceremony or non-actionable clarification versus phase1_control." }, "authority_profile": [ "existing artifact is read-only", "reviewer may report but not decide target WHAT" ], "inputs": [ { "path": "existing-product-contract.md", "content": "已有 PRD 包含 Summary、Requirements、Acceptance Examples 和一个未闭合权限问题；运行前后由 mutation sentinel 比较 bytes、mtime、receipt 和目录内容。" } ], "review_focus": [ "report-only behavior", "actionable blocker diagnosis", "no rewrite/finalize/runtime/design materialization" ] }, { "id": "critical-design-degraded-authority", "gate_role": "gate_a_critical", "intent": "design", "minimum_material_effect": null, "authority_profile": [ "design proposal is partial and not approved", "current user cannot substitute missing design authority" ], "inputs": [ { "path": "design-evidence.md", "content": "Figma 只读证据仅覆盖默认态；权限拒绝态节点不可读，approval authority unknown。该状态会改变页面反馈与验收。" } ], "review_focus": [ "degraded consequence", "authority fidelity", "no provider mutation or invented approved state" ] }, { "id": "critical-domain-signoff-timing", "gate_role": "gate_a_critical", "intent": "domain", "minimum_material_effect": null, "authority_profile": [ "specialist owns regulated claim", "current user is question recipient only" ], "inputs": [ { "path": "domain-constraint.md", "content": "资金冻结提示文案需要 before-planning 专业会签；当前材料只有模型建议和未批准的历史草稿。" } ], "review_focus": [ "sign-off timing", "claim-specific authority", "checkpoint until specialist evidence" ] }, { "id": "critical-stress-multisource", "gate_role": "gate_a_critical", "intent": "stress", "minimum_material_effect": null, "authority_profile": [ "user owns release scope", "meeting owns ratified target decision", "code owns current state", "design and domain claims require separate authority" ], "inputs": [ { "path": "stress-input.md", "content": "组合输入包含粗 PRD、已批准会议决定、冲突代码、部分可读 Figma、专业会签要求和项目规则。必须闭合本期 WHAT，同时保留 unread design 与 specialist blocker。" } ], "review_focus": [ "source authority reconciliation", "release-bounded closure", "critical residue", "right-size and readability" ] }, { "id": "routing-trigger-matrix", "gate_role": "trigger_matrix", "intent": "trigger-matrix", "minimum_material_effect": null, "authority_profile": [ "routing only; scored separately from output quality" ], "should_trigger": [ "source-resolvable brownfield framing", "API/SDK external product surface", "current release-slice PRD/meeting/code/design reconciliation" ], "near_miss": [ "unbounded 0-1 product exploration", "mutually exclusive unresolved product shapes", "implementation plan", "debugging request", "mobile App full-system consistency audit", "non-App full-system consistency audit", "format-only document cleanup" ], "inputs": [], "review_focus": [ "route precision", "no output-quality score mixing" ] } ] }