{
  "corpus_version": "seed-v1",
  "generation_model": "claude-sonnet-4-6",
  "judge_model": "claude-sonnet-4-6",
  "benchmark_date": "2026-06-22",
  "note": "Full A-vs-B-vs-C benchmark. Arm A = ForgeDock harness (archetype sampling + anti-slop + critique). Arm B = raw one-shot. Slipstream arm C viewport-only (vercel.com rendering issue).",
  "products": [
    {
      "product": "cadence",
      "reference": "resend.com",
      "runs": [
        {
          "run": 1,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "C", "B_vs_C": "C", "A_vs_B": "B"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 3, "typography": 3, "color": 3, "whitespace": 2, "originality": 2, "mobile": 3},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 4, "color": 4, "whitespace": 3, "originality": 3, "mobile": 4},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 5, "color": 5, "whitespace": 5, "originality": 5, "mobile": 5}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 4, "B": 3, "C": 0}
        },
        {
          "run": 2,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "C", "B_vs_C": "C", "A_vs_B": "tie"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 3, "typography": 4, "color": 3, "whitespace": 3, "originality": 3, "mobile": 3},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 4, "color": 4, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 3, "mobile": 4},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 5, "color": 5, "whitespace": 5, "originality": 5, "mobile": 5}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 3, "B": 4, "C": 0}
        },
        {
          "run": 3,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "C", "B_vs_C": "C", "A_vs_B": "B"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 3, "typography": 3, "color": 2, "whitespace": 2, "originality": 2, "mobile": 3},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 4, "color": 3, "whitespace": 3, "originality": 3, "mobile": 4},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 5, "color": 5, "whitespace": 5, "originality": 5, "mobile": 5}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 5, "B": 3, "C": 0}
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "product": "tender",
      "reference": "stripe.com",
      "runs": [
        {
          "run": 1,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "C", "B_vs_C": "C", "A_vs_B": "A"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 4, "color": 4, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 3, "mobile": 3},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 3, "typography": 3, "color": 2, "whitespace": 3, "originality": 2, "mobile": 3},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 5, "color": 5, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 5, "mobile": 4}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 1, "B": 3, "C": 1}
        },
        {
          "run": 2,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "C", "B_vs_C": "C", "A_vs_B": "B"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 3, "typography": 4, "color": 3, "whitespace": 2, "originality": 3, "mobile": 2},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 4, "color": 3, "whitespace": 3, "originality": 3, "mobile": 3},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 5, "color": 5, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 5, "mobile": 4}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 2, "B": 2, "C": 1}
        },
        {
          "run": 3,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "C", "B_vs_C": "C", "A_vs_B": "A"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 4, "color": 4, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 4, "mobile": 3},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 3, "typography": 3, "color": 3, "whitespace": 3, "originality": 2, "mobile": 3},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 5, "color": 5, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 5, "mobile": 4}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 1, "B": 3, "C": 1}
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "product": "slipstream",
      "reference": "vercel.com",
      "note": "Arm C viewport-only (vercel.com rendering timeout). A_vs_C and B_vs_C comparisons may be miscalibrated.",
      "runs": [
        {
          "run": 1,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "A", "B_vs_C": "B", "A_vs_B": "A"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 4, "color": 4, "whitespace": 3, "originality": 5, "mobile": 3},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 3, "color": 3, "whitespace": 3, "originality": 3, "mobile": 3},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 5, "color": 4, "whitespace": 5, "originality": 4, "mobile": 4}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 1, "B": 2, "C": 0}
        },
        {
          "run": 2,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "C", "B_vs_C": "C", "A_vs_B": "A"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 4, "color": 3, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 3, "mobile": 3},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 4, "color": 4, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 3, "mobile": 4},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 5, "color": 4, "whitespace": 5, "originality": 4, "mobile": 4}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 2, "B": 1, "C": 0}
        },
        {
          "run": 3,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "A", "B_vs_C": "B", "A_vs_B": "A"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 4, "color": 4, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 4, "mobile": 4},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 3, "color": 3, "whitespace": 3, "originality": 3, "mobile": 3},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 5, "color": 4, "whitespace": 5, "originality": 4, "mobile": 4}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 1, "B": 3, "C": 0}
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "product": "voltage",
      "reference": "modal.com",
      "runs": [
        {
          "run": 1,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "C", "B_vs_C": "C", "A_vs_B": "A"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 4, "color": 4, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 3, "mobile": 3},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 3, "typography": 3, "color": 3, "whitespace": 3, "originality": 2, "mobile": 3},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 4, "color": 5, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 4, "mobile": 4}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 1, "B": 3, "C": 1}
        },
        {
          "run": 2,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "C", "B_vs_C": "C", "A_vs_B": "A"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 5, "color": 5, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 5, "mobile": 3},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 3, "typography": 3, "color": 3, "whitespace": 3, "originality": 3, "mobile": 3},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 4, "color": 5, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 4, "mobile": 4}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 0, "B": 2, "C": 1}
        },
        {
          "run": 3,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "C", "B_vs_C": "C", "A_vs_B": "A"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 5, "color": 4, "whitespace": 5, "originality": 4, "mobile": 4},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 3, "typography": 2, "color": 2, "whitespace": 2, "originality": 2, "mobile": 2},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 4, "color": 5, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 4, "mobile": 4}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 1, "B": 4, "C": 1}
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "product": "plume",
      "reference": "linear.app",
      "runs": [
        {
          "run": 1,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "C", "B_vs_C": "C", "A_vs_B": "B"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 2, "typography": 3, "color": 2, "whitespace": 3, "originality": 3, "mobile": 2},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 4, "color": 4, "whitespace": 3, "originality": 3, "mobile": 4},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 5, "color": 5, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 4, "mobile": 4}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 1, "B": 3, "C": 2}
        },
        {
          "run": 2,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "C", "B_vs_C": "C", "A_vs_B": "A"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 4, "color": 4, "whitespace": 3, "originality": 5, "mobile": 3},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 4, "typography": 4, "color": 4, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 4, "mobile": 4},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 5, "color": 5, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 4, "mobile": 4}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 2, "B": 3, "C": 2}
        },
        {
          "run": 3,
          "pairwise": {"A_vs_C": "C", "B_vs_C": "C", "A_vs_B": "B"},
          "rubric": {
            "A": {"hierarchy": 3, "typography": 4, "color": 3, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 4, "mobile": 2},
            "B": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 4, "color": 4, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 4, "mobile": 4},
            "C": {"hierarchy": 5, "typography": 5, "color": 5, "whitespace": 4, "originality": 4, "mobile": 4}
          },
          "slop": {"A": 1, "B": 2, "C": 2}
        }
      ]
    }
  ]
}