# Critic review packet

Use only when an independent critic review is requested. Keep the packet
bounded; omit conversation history, raw logs, abandoned approaches, secrets,
private data, and broad repository scans.

## Candidate

- Repository:
- Base commit:
- Candidate commit or immutable snapshot:
- Changed files:

## Purpose and boundaries

- Requested outcome:
- Explicit exclusions:
- Acceptance checklist:
- Direct authority files/sections:

## Evidence

- Focused tests and results:
- Known risks or unresolved questions:

## Requested report

Return one consolidated report containing:

1. Critical/high findings with exact file/line or reproducible evidence.
2. Impact and required correction for each finding.
3. Lower-severity observations separately.
4. Final disposition: accept, accept after listed corrections, or reject.

Do not edit the candidate and do not report style preferences as blocking.
If the bounded review finds no defect, say so and name the inspected evidence;
never invent a finding to satisfy a quota.