{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "read_pass_date": "2026-07-14",
  "project": "claudeconsult-maginnis",
  "source": "Full-read review of all 240 pending knowledge-extraction drafts (not sampled). Original disposition applied via a scratchpad script (transcript d7292bdd-ccb6-4646-9893-64253d97a4e1.jsonl, session 2026-07-14) that held 13 true specimens plus one item held in error under a mislabeled reason. This fixture is the durable, version-controlled answer key — the queue itself is user-level state, not committed, and annotateItemEvidence refuses writes to non-pending items, so a classifier cannot be validated against a key stored in the store it writes to (see plan retrospective-reclassification.md, Edge case 1).",
  "disposition": {
    "captured_to_memory": {
      "count": 219,
      "resolution_type": "captured-to-memory",
      "note": "Written to the claudeconsult-maginnis memory dir and resolved in one applyBatch call on 2026-07-14. Reachable via the existing lesson*/decision*/constraint*/preference* MEMORY.md region pointers — zero new index lines.",
      "ids": [
        "dec-00951423",
        "dec-0114306d",
        "dec-0119e2f6",
        "dec-01fcbb24",
        "dec-0272d18a",
        "dec-02cd1a09",
        "dec-05cad7bc",
        "dec-0748c63c",
        "dec-09e3b392",
        "dec-0ab0aed6",
        "dec-0b5336d4",
        "dec-0c07f249",
        "dec-0cb96842",
        "dec-0ec38cf4",
        "dec-1041a5d1",
        "dec-10e385cc",
        "dec-115629d3",
        "dec-124a8691",
        "dec-148ca6a6",
        "dec-1570429d",
        "dec-158030a2",
        "dec-18084acc",
        "dec-18fee818",
        "dec-19692df6",
        "dec-1a329dbe",
        "dec-1bb077bc",
        "dec-1d05df50",
        "dec-1d820ccb",
        "dec-1ebcec87",
        "dec-1fffb5c9",
        "dec-200c8625",
        "dec-20328fb7",
        "dec-206cbd22",
        "dec-234e62d8",
        "dec-24627af6",
        "dec-253193d1",
        "dec-26ba7644",
        "dec-26d0556e",
        "dec-29622701",
        "dec-2a235730",
        "dec-2c0b98ff",
        "dec-2c23c3c0",
        "dec-2e06302b",
        "dec-2f956a0b",
        "dec-323363b5",
        "dec-323f4e25",
        "dec-386c76a2",
        "dec-3a1ebaa9",
        "dec-3b4ecd34",
        "dec-3b64644c",
        "dec-3cc5df49",
        "dec-3df40cd6",
        "dec-3e719f79",
        "dec-3fec41e0",
        "dec-405d1bea",
        "dec-434e61bf",
        "dec-46b4b29b",
        "dec-473ff67b",
        "dec-48be5f1b",
        "dec-49ebdff6",
        "dec-4b0bc470",
        "dec-4b39ad09",
        "dec-4b8b8b8b",
        "dec-4d6631c9",
        "dec-4ef8588f",
        "dec-4f9dd2c8",
        "dec-53417012",
        "dec-550189ff",
        "dec-56cd26d5",
        "dec-5849b8c2",
        "dec-595f234a",
        "dec-5a13b0ef",
        "dec-5bca8f80",
        "dec-5c4dbb74",
        "dec-5c82042c",
        "dec-5d3d00ad",
        "dec-5d6e1baa",
        "dec-5d7ab1e8",
        "dec-5e321485",
        "dec-5e432a14",
        "dec-5e4337a3",
        "dec-6123110a",
        "dec-61526ad7",
        "dec-62244602",
        "dec-62f6a85e",
        "dec-68157ed3",
        "dec-681750dc",
        "dec-697142c8",
        "dec-6996f542",
        "dec-6b70809b",
        "dec-6d40cc84",
        "dec-6dbf2001",
        "dec-6e3ed922",
        "dec-6e573ae6",
        "dec-6f151501",
        "dec-70f11fc9",
        "dec-715a135e",
        "dec-7189b8bb",
        "dec-721c8a43",
        "dec-74ed562b",
        "dec-7a191985",
        "dec-7ae6de81",
        "dec-7b5fd3ae",
        "dec-7d626053",
        "dec-7db5045c",
        "dec-7dce6d6e",
        "dec-7de71f34",
        "dec-7dfc3bac",
        "dec-7e169030",
        "dec-7e679ec8",
        "dec-7eb48c24",
        "dec-800d2528",
        "dec-80cd1213",
        "dec-837d172c",
        "dec-8491283e",
        "dec-850e8f10",
        "dec-8530e07f",
        "dec-8686506d",
        "dec-868b5712",
        "dec-8774a250",
        "dec-886813c5",
        "dec-891c9916",
        "dec-8be28c12",
        "dec-8f4393fe",
        "dec-8f455b1f",
        "dec-90113d46",
        "dec-90914432",
        "dec-933d27b5",
        "dec-941e06ac",
        "dec-94c8aa37",
        "dec-96c66ca1",
        "dec-995f745c",
        "dec-9ca91b6b",
        "dec-9d128b60",
        "dec-9d553045",
        "dec-9d8741e6",
        "dec-9dd128b0",
        "dec-a2772dfc",
        "dec-a67c536d",
        "dec-ac687f3e",
        "dec-ac7838db",
        "dec-ad9098d5",
        "dec-aed25e3a",
        "dec-aef29fc5",
        "dec-b0f90148",
        "dec-b11648ab",
        "dec-b1510bf7",
        "dec-b1f6e797",
        "dec-b22b2c79",
        "dec-b34907c8",
        "dec-b3940c06",
        "dec-b44d815b",
        "dec-b53a975f",
        "dec-b53ce1fb",
        "dec-b6036024",
        "dec-b7e3069b",
        "dec-b96aa610",
        "dec-ba1a57b6",
        "dec-bacfa02a",
        "dec-bb05f511",
        "dec-bc762b75",
        "dec-bce48d0c",
        "dec-bd6ce1f9",
        "dec-be02965b",
        "dec-c04449a5",
        "dec-c1f5fe56",
        "dec-c5444c88",
        "dec-c596a038",
        "dec-c67eeed0",
        "dec-c75ab540",
        "dec-c7dbc673",
        "dec-c89cc8ec",
        "dec-c9959c98",
        "dec-ca736b7e",
        "dec-ccb30841",
        "dec-d0ed46de",
        "dec-d108bc83",
        "dec-d2ad5209",
        "dec-d30c5a1d",
        "dec-d44522de",
        "dec-d4d9df68",
        "dec-d51333d4",
        "dec-d5877bce",
        "dec-d68031e4",
        "dec-d77e534d",
        "dec-d7b7cd62",
        "dec-d98ac311",
        "dec-dcebd69f",
        "dec-dea09a70",
        "dec-deb692d2",
        "dec-df09371d",
        "dec-e063cb3a",
        "dec-e095dbb8",
        "dec-e0e98c70",
        "dec-e3399516",
        "dec-e424ae9c",
        "dec-e4ad9783",
        "dec-e646b7f4",
        "dec-e82db269",
        "dec-e8b5a64b",
        "dec-e9cecf41",
        "dec-ecfbee7e",
        "dec-ee606b83",
        "dec-eedb5877",
        "dec-f142a4b2",
        "dec-f189147f",
        "dec-f20aa140",
        "dec-f3841545",
        "dec-f4a2a84d",
        "dec-f4aca557",
        "dec-f5aa2bd9",
        "dec-f76a3401",
        "dec-f76a984e",
        "dec-f7d71240",
        "dec-f8a2b956",
        "dec-f9546a5a",
        "dec-fe670526",
        "dec-ff17a13d",
        "dec-ff205d11"
      ]
    },
    "specimens": {
      "count": 13,
      "note": "Deliberately held pending by the read-pass as worked examples for the retrospective-temporality durability-classifier design (N2-N5) — not draft defects. Marked via the new holdItem verb (act:346e6212) on 2026-07-20, carrying evidence.held + evidence.specimen.{class, reason}.",
      "items": [
        {
          "id": "dec-337455f6",
          "class": "contradiction",
          "reason": "deploy-state contradiction: says prod+staging at ccdcefb"
        },
        {
          "id": "dec-b85dbfbb",
          "class": "contradiction",
          "reason": "deploy-state contradiction: says prod at 35a5d15, 4 undeployed"
        },
        {
          "id": "dec-0a08e1fa",
          "class": "duplicate-pair",
          "reason": "dup pair A (cause phrasing): JSONB replace is read-merge-write"
        },
        {
          "id": "dec-5a98f8fb",
          "class": "duplicate-pair",
          "reason": "dup pair A (effect phrasing): partial JSONB write destroys omitted keys"
        },
        {
          "id": "dec-8a1bb91e",
          "class": "duplicate-pair",
          "reason": "dup pair B: Mailchimp omit status on existing members — duplicate of dec-837d172c, already captured to memory (the escaped pair)"
        },
        {
          "id": "dec-02aa0847",
          "class": "duplicate-pair",
          "reason": "dup pair C: concurrent rebases — resolve by inspection"
        },
        {
          "id": "dec-3518ba3a",
          "class": "duplicate-pair",
          "reason": "dup pair C: debrief doc-conflict — resolve by inspection"
        },
        {
          "id": "dec-80e79886",
          "class": "near-contradiction",
          "reason": "near-contradiction with pair C: recommends checkout --ours + re-apply"
        },
        {
          "id": "dec-2a863d90",
          "class": "supersession",
          "reason": "superseded: Meta server-to-server dedup marked \"unverified\""
        },
        {
          "id": "dec-0b9e82e3",
          "class": "supersession",
          "reason": "supersedes the above: verified Meta does NOT dedup server-to-server"
        },
        {
          "id": "dec-6c76431d",
          "class": "point-in-time",
          "reason": "point-in-time: arb census already ran; u-haul notes now stale"
        },
        {
          "id": "dec-090442bc",
          "class": "point-in-time",
          "reason": "point-in-time: invoice #1 boundary 95.25h / unbilled 24.0h"
        },
        {
          "id": "dec-a2a39144",
          "class": "point-in-time",
          "reason": "point-in-time: Ed at 581 plugin calls/30d, prod-only"
        }
      ]
    },
    "held_in_error": {
      "id": "dec-3609fe4a",
      "original_mislabel": "dup pair B: Mailchimp never send status key",
      "actual_content": "lesson: CP3 cabinet members independently flagged query-ceiling regression from unmemoized FirmDetail reads in JSON-LD — unrelated to Mailchimp",
      "cause": "Hand-transcription error in the original scratchpad HOLD map (a Map literal built by hand-copying hex ids) — the exact error class the new holdItem verb (id taken from the item under review, never retyped) makes structurally impossible.",
      "resolution": "Released 2026-07-20 (act:346e6212): written to memory and resolved captured-to-memory, the same disposition as its 219 peers. Not a specimen."
    },
    "escaped_duplicate": {
      "written_to_memory": "dec-837d172c",
      "written_to_memory_title": "lesson: Mailchimp upsert must never send a status key — preserves Mailchimp-side unsubscribe",
      "still_pending_duplicate": "dec-8a1bb91e",
      "still_pending_duplicate_title": "lesson: Mailchimp API: omit status field on existing members to prevent accidental resubscription",
      "note": "Same lesson, cause-vs-effect phrasing shares almost no vocabulary — the lexical fold-detector (unigram Jaccard) could not pair them. dec-8a1bb91e is correctly held as specimen class duplicate-pair; its true duplicate partner already lives in memory as dec-837d172c, not dec-3609fe4a (the mislabeled entry above). This is the specimen N5 fixes the fold-similarity function against."
    }
  },
  "totals": {
    "captured_to_memory": 219,
    "specimens": 13,
    "held_in_error": 1,
    "accounted_for": 233
  }
}