# Clarifications - {{FEATURE_NAME_TITLE}}

**Feature**: {{FEATURE_NAME}}
**Date**: {{DATE}}
**Phase**: CLARIFY (Phase 3)
**Status**: {{#if status}}{{status}}{{else}}In Progress{{/if}}

---

## Purpose

This document addresses ambiguities, edge cases, and questions identified during the design review. All clarifications should be incorporated back into `spec.md` after approval.

---

## Questions & Answers

{{#each questions}}
### Q{{this.id}}: {{this.category}} - {{this.title}}

**Question:**
{{this.question}}

**Context:**
{{this.context}}

**Answer:**
{{this.answer}}

**Impact:**
{{this.impact}}

**Spec Updates Required:**
{{#each this.specUpdates}}
- {{this}}
{{/each}}

**Priority:** {{this.priority}}
**Resolved:** {{#if this.resolved}}✅ Yes{{else}}❌ No{{/if}}
**Resolved By:** {{#if this.resolvedBy}}{{this.resolvedBy}}{{else}}_Pending_{{/if}}

---
{{/each}}

## Edge Cases Identified

{{#each edgeCases}}
### EC{{@index}}: {{this.title}}

**Scenario:**
{{this.scenario}}

**Current Behavior:**
{{this.currentBehavior}}

**Expected Behavior:**
{{this.expectedBehavior}}

**Proposed Solution:**
{{this.proposedSolution}}

**Acceptance Criteria:**
{{#each this.acceptanceCriteria}}
- [ ] {{this}}
{{/each}}

**Affected Components:**
{{#each this.affectedComponents}}
- {{this}}
{{/each}}

---
{{/each}}

## Assumptions Validated

{{#each assumptions}}
### A{{@index}}: {{this.title}}

**Assumption:**
{{this.description}}

**Validation:**
{{#if this.validated}}✅ Confirmed{{else}}❌ Invalid{{/if}}

**Notes:**
{{this.notes}}

**Action Required:**
{{#if this.action}}{{this.action}}{{else}}_None_{{/if}}

---
{{/each}}

## Business Rules Clarified

{{#each businessRules}}
### BR{{@index}}: {{this.title}}

**Rule:**
{{this.rule}}

**Rationale:**
{{this.rationale}}

**Examples:**
{{#each this.examples}}
- {{this}}
{{/each}}

**Exceptions:**
{{#if this.exceptions}}
{{#each this.exceptions}}
- {{this}}
{{/each}}
{{else}}
_None_
{{/if}}

---
{{/each}}

## Data Validation Rules

{{#each dataValidations}}
### DV{{@index}}: {{this.field}} Validation

**Field:** {{this.field}}
**Entity:** {{this.entity}}

**Validation Rules:**
{{#each this.rules}}
- {{this}}
{{/each}}

**Error Messages:**
{{#each this.errorMessages}}
- {{this.condition}}: "{{this.message}}"
{{/each}}

**Impact on UX:**
{{this.uxImpact}}

---
{{/each}}

## Performance & Scalability Clarifications

{{#each performanceClarifications}}
### PC{{@index}}: {{this.title}}

**Concern:**
{{this.concern}}

**Clarification:**
{{this.clarification}}

**Solution:**
{{this.solution}}

**Performance Target:**
{{this.target}}

---
{{/each}}

## Security & Authorization Clarifications

{{#each securityClarifications}}
### SC{{@index}}: {{this.title}}

**Security Concern:**
{{this.concern}}

**Clarification:**
{{this.clarification}}

**Implementation:**
{{this.implementation}}

**Affected Roles:**
{{#each this.affectedRoles}}
- {{this}}
{{/each}}

---
{{/each}}

## Integration & External Dependencies

{{#each integrationClarifications}}
### IC{{@index}}: {{this.title}}

**External System:**
{{this.externalSystem}}

**Question:**
{{this.question}}

**Clarification:**
{{this.clarification}}

**API Endpoint/Method:**
{{this.apiDetails}}

**Error Handling:**
{{this.errorHandling}}

---
{{/each}}

## Summary

**Total Questions:** {{#if totalQuestions}}{{totalQuestions}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
**Resolved:** {{#if resolvedCount}}{{resolvedCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
**Pending:** {{#if pendingCount}}{{pendingCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}

**Edge Cases Identified:** {{#if edgeCaseCount}}{{edgeCaseCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
**Business Rules Documented:** {{#if businessRuleCount}}{{businessRuleCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
**Assumptions Validated:** {{#if assumptionCount}}{{assumptionCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}

---

## Next Steps

1. [ ] Resolve all pending questions
2. [ ] Update `spec.md` with all clarifications
3. [ ] Update `contracts.cs` if data model changes are needed
4. [ ] Document breaking changes in `decisions.md`
5. [ ] Get stakeholder approval on all clarifications
6. [ ] Advance to Phase 4 (Tasks)

---

## Spec Updates Log

**Changes to be made to `spec.md`:**

{{#each specUpdates}}
### Update {{@index}}

**Section:** {{this.section}}
**Type:** {{this.type}}
**Description:** {{this.description}}
**From Clarification:** {{this.clarificationId}}

---
{{/each}}

---

*Generated by MORPH-SPEC v{{FRAMEWORK_VERSION}}*
*All clarifications must be incorporated into spec.md before advancing to Phase 4*