{ "schemaVersion": "ucr.live-multimodel-handoff/1", "evidenceClass": "live-multimodel-executable-smoke-not-powered-effectiveness", "executedAt": "2026-08-10T02:10:43.751Z", "sourceTreeHash": "9361d24561616599b123af79f622b421e8690be06be7dbd83899ea2e713a26f3", "requestedDirections": [ "codex->claude-code" ], "directionsPassed": 1, "directionResults": [ { "study": "cross-client-handoff", "direction": "codex->claude-code", "producerClient": "codex", "consumerClient": "claude-code", "producerFamily": "openai", "consumerFamily": "anthropic", "producerModel": "gpt-5.6-sol", "consumerModel": "sonnet", "taskHash": "f422f7b1403bb5da4824770ba224505691f834e022e0c76bc891a5f9585da3ef", "control": { "exitCode": 0, "correct": true, "abstained": false, "mistakeExecuted": false, "outcomeGrade": { "passed": true, "protectedFilesUnchanged": true, "canonicalSourceChanged": true, "generatedSynchronized": true, "verifierExitCode": 0, "verifierOutput": "verification passed", "sourceHash": "5fe684e5cbcac69214d77b1f94a198811c55a71ee2529f6cf270840022deda46", "generatedHash": "245214c35d7bbfcc764b5d1c8fab218c9ce76cda6e436a2d2f426877d5410d2a" }, "usage": { "inputTokens": 279144, "cachedInputTokens": 265988, "outputTokens": 1814, "totalTokens": 280958, "costUsd": 0.18662540000000002, "tokenAccounting": "provider-cli-native-logical-input" }, "latencyMs": 30845 }, "producer": { "exitCode": 0, "recorded": true, "modelAuthored": true, "evidenceAuthenticatedBeforeAuthoring": true, "predecessorMistakeObserved": true, "predecessorCorrectionVerified": true, "predecessorEvidence": { "trigger": "continuing implementation task multimodel-codex-claude-code-537b7817cb994766", "attemptedAction": "apply implementation choice EDIT-GENERATED-CLIENT-HOOK", "observedFailure": "regeneration verifier rejected EDIT-GENERATED-CLIENT-HOOK after overwriting the direct generated-hook edit", "rootCause": "client hook copies are generated from hooks-core and direct edits do not survive synchronization", "correction": "apply verified implementation choice EDIT-HOOKS-CORE-THEN-SYNC", "verificationEvidence": "external audit observed failed regeneration followed by a passing end-state grade for EDIT-HOOKS-CORE-THEN-SYNC", "expectedOutcome": "task multimodel-codex-claude-code-537b7817cb994766 updates hooks-core, regenerates clients, and does not repeat EDIT-GENERATED-CLIENT-HOOK", "staleAttemptObserved": true, "correctionObserved": true, "correctedAttemptAccepted": true, "auditHash": "f5dce5e6d60e3c280823d0e601d8764150fb6f793cf30dc644b88d74146f8559", "finalGrade": { "passed": true, "protectedFilesUnchanged": true, "canonicalSourceChanged": true, "generatedSynchronized": true, "verifierExitCode": 0, "verifierOutput": "verification passed", "sourceHash": "5fe684e5cbcac69214d77b1f94a198811c55a71ee2529f6cf270840022deda46", "generatedHash": "245214c35d7bbfcc764b5d1c8fab218c9ce76cda6e436a2d2f426877d5410d2a" } }, "semanticHarvestReceipt": { "schemaVersion": "ucr.semantic-harvest-receipt/1", "modelAuthored": true, "evidenceAuthenticatedBeforeAuthoring": true, "kind": "failure", "taskId": "multimodel-codex-claude-code-537b7817cb994766", "attempts": 1, "modelOutputHash": "6fb3daf604e5f7129474f03cb1468d63bb390f921c6ba5a9e6a792fe90a820c3", "semanticObjectHash": "f891fc14425496db314cb5b55c18690584a8cd0e5690666efa3439e8d3746d30", "activatedObjectId": "failure:8121ff635eebf07f29888e8b", "eventIds": [ "019fe96e-b4ed-787b-bcbb-5618ca792203", "019fe96e-b4ee-7b32-9807-f8012dccd2f3", "019fe96e-b4ef-71be-8129-4de87c37085d", "019fe96e-b4ef-742f-86ab-c3f129eec884" ], "receiptHash": "948afbc97421cb83d4376eeae7f0766e6b6024794bdba0ee554213d7555e85cf" }, "workUsage": { "inputTokens": 83354, "cachedInputTokens": 72192, "outputTokens": 830, "totalTokens": null, "costUsd": null, "tokenAccounting": "provider-cli-native" }, "harvestUsage": { "inputTokens": 14034, "cachedInputTokens": 0, "outputTokens": 405, "totalTokens": null, "costUsd": null, "tokenAccounting": "provider-cli-native", "invocations": 1 }, "usage": { "inputTokens": 97388, "cachedInputTokens": 72192, "outputTokens": 1235, "totalTokens": null, "costUsd": null, "tokenAccounting": "provider-cli-native", "invocations": 2 }, "latencyMs": 50552 }, "runtime": { "exitCode": 0, "correct": true, "delivered": true, "selected": true, "retrievalAttempted": true, "attested": false, "attestationFailed": false, "deliveryPhase": "adapter-pre-action", "mistakeExecuted": false, "outcomeGrade": { "passed": true, "protectedFilesUnchanged": true, "canonicalSourceChanged": true, "generatedSynchronized": true, "verifierExitCode": 0, "verifierOutput": "verification passed", "sourceHash": "5fe684e5cbcac69214d77b1f94a198811c55a71ee2529f6cf270840022deda46", "generatedHash": "245214c35d7bbfcc764b5d1c8fab218c9ce76cda6e436a2d2f426877d5410d2a" }, "usage": { "inputTokens": 337693, "cachedInputTokens": 321095, "outputTokens": 5127, "totalTokens": 342820, "costUsd": 0.27277350000000006, "tokenAccounting": "provider-cli-native-logical-input", "staticSchemaTokens": 0, "capsuleTokens": 212, "instructionTokens": 271 }, "latencyMs": 64639, "preflightLatencyMs": 137, "consumerMcpExposed": false, "preActionReceipt": { "schemaVersion": "ucr.pre-action-receipt/1", "retrievalAttempted": true, "action": "deliver", "delivered": true, "taskId": "multimodel-codex-claude-code-537b7817cb994766", "sessionId": "consumer-session", "trigger": "task", "budget": 384, "capsuleIds": [ "capsule:b95042748125e8131f7a1f3a" ], "objectIds": [ "failure:8121ff635eebf07f29888e8b" ], "capsuleTokens": 212, "injectionTokens": 271, "staticSchemaTokens": 0, "consumerMcpExposed": false, "exposedTools": [], "injectionChannel": "claude-session-start-hook-additional-context", "deliveryEventId": "019fe96e-b57c-7de5-a978-695fcecc335c", "latencyMs": 137, "receiptHash": "0caf3391bc337a77ff83bd234f8b36a6aaacb5d8febc8793d75f56b470178ded" } }, "eventStreamHash": "c4fccf2c6be8b5c4f7a5d17c58e78d53f9650317379197609e2161119ef147fb", "canonicalEvents": 5, "passed": true, "transcriptPublished": false } ], "clients": { "codex": { "family": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "version": "codex-cli 0.147.0" }, "claude-code": { "family": "anthropic", "model": "sonnet", "version": "2.1.225 (Claude Code)" }, "copilot": { "family": "anthropic", "model": "claude-sonnet-4.5", "version": "GitHub Copilot CLI 0.0.396.\nRun 'copilot update' to check for updates." } }, "modelFamilies": 2, "attestationSurface": { "profile": "attestation", "toolNames": [ "context_receipt_verify" ], "schemaTokens": 71, "tokenAccounting": "tiktoken:cl100k_base" }, "controlsAbstained": 0, "repeatedVerifiedFailures": 0, "ledger": { "schemaVersion": "ucr.evidence-ledger/2", "evidenceClass": "executable-smoke", "run": { "schemaVersion": "ucr.evidence-run/2", "runId": "live-multimodel-4713afb92c757e6a", "evidenceClass": "executable-smoke", "benchmarkHash": "4b2148b8a73d20f9d94a3008e1756f9fb38144818bb527b752ec5ff6ffa06f0e", "sourceTreeHash": "9361d24561616599b123af79f622b421e8690be06be7dbd83899ea2e713a26f3", "runner": { "name": "live-multimodel-handoff", "versions": { "codex": "codex-cli 0.147.0", "claude-code": "2.1.225 (Claude Code)", "copilot": "GitHub Copilot CLI 0.0.396.\nRun 'copilot update' to check for updates." } }, "startedAt": "2026-08-10T02:10:43.747Z", "runHash": "475616c62aa856747b9291d73ce4be39d98df9ea538a35362237ca37218b172f" }, "rows": [ { "study": "cross-client-handoff", "direction": "codex->claude-code", "producerClient": "codex", "consumerClient": "claude-code", "producerFamily": "openai", "consumerFamily": "anthropic", "producerModel": "gpt-5.6-sol", "consumerModel": "sonnet", "taskHash": "f422f7b1403bb5da4824770ba224505691f834e022e0c76bc891a5f9585da3ef", "control": { "exitCode": 0, "correct": true, "abstained": false, "mistakeExecuted": false, "outcomeGrade": { "passed": true, "protectedFilesUnchanged": true, "canonicalSourceChanged": true, "generatedSynchronized": true, "verifierExitCode": 0, "verifierOutput": "verification passed", "sourceHash": "5fe684e5cbcac69214d77b1f94a198811c55a71ee2529f6cf270840022deda46", "generatedHash": "245214c35d7bbfcc764b5d1c8fab218c9ce76cda6e436a2d2f426877d5410d2a" }, "usage": { "inputTokens": 279144, "cachedInputTokens": 265988, "outputTokens": 1814, "totalTokens": 280958, "costUsd": 0.18662540000000002, "tokenAccounting": "provider-cli-native-logical-input" }, "latencyMs": 30845 }, "producer": { "exitCode": 0, "recorded": true, "modelAuthored": true, "evidenceAuthenticatedBeforeAuthoring": true, "predecessorMistakeObserved": true, "predecessorCorrectionVerified": true, "predecessorEvidence": { "trigger": "continuing implementation task multimodel-codex-claude-code-537b7817cb994766", "attemptedAction": "apply implementation choice EDIT-GENERATED-CLIENT-HOOK", "observedFailure": "regeneration verifier rejected EDIT-GENERATED-CLIENT-HOOK after overwriting the direct generated-hook edit", "rootCause": "client hook copies are generated from hooks-core and direct edits do not survive synchronization", "correction": "apply verified implementation choice EDIT-HOOKS-CORE-THEN-SYNC", "verificationEvidence": "external audit observed failed regeneration followed by a passing end-state grade for EDIT-HOOKS-CORE-THEN-SYNC", "expectedOutcome": "task multimodel-codex-claude-code-537b7817cb994766 updates hooks-core, regenerates clients, and does not repeat EDIT-GENERATED-CLIENT-HOOK", "staleAttemptObserved": true, "correctionObserved": true, "correctedAttemptAccepted": true, "auditHash": "f5dce5e6d60e3c280823d0e601d8764150fb6f793cf30dc644b88d74146f8559", "finalGrade": { "passed": true, "protectedFilesUnchanged": true, "canonicalSourceChanged": true, "generatedSynchronized": true, "verifierExitCode": 0, "verifierOutput": "verification passed", "sourceHash": "5fe684e5cbcac69214d77b1f94a198811c55a71ee2529f6cf270840022deda46", "generatedHash": "245214c35d7bbfcc764b5d1c8fab218c9ce76cda6e436a2d2f426877d5410d2a" } }, "semanticHarvestReceipt": { "schemaVersion": "ucr.semantic-harvest-receipt/1", "modelAuthored": true, "evidenceAuthenticatedBeforeAuthoring": true, "kind": "failure", "taskId": "multimodel-codex-claude-code-537b7817cb994766", "attempts": 1, "modelOutputHash": "6fb3daf604e5f7129474f03cb1468d63bb390f921c6ba5a9e6a792fe90a820c3", "semanticObjectHash": "f891fc14425496db314cb5b55c18690584a8cd0e5690666efa3439e8d3746d30", "activatedObjectId": "failure:8121ff635eebf07f29888e8b", "eventIds": [ "019fe96e-b4ed-787b-bcbb-5618ca792203", "019fe96e-b4ee-7b32-9807-f8012dccd2f3", "019fe96e-b4ef-71be-8129-4de87c37085d", "019fe96e-b4ef-742f-86ab-c3f129eec884" ], "receiptHash": "948afbc97421cb83d4376eeae7f0766e6b6024794bdba0ee554213d7555e85cf" }, "workUsage": { "inputTokens": 83354, "cachedInputTokens": 72192, "outputTokens": 830, "totalTokens": null, "costUsd": null, "tokenAccounting": "provider-cli-native" }, "harvestUsage": { "inputTokens": 14034, "cachedInputTokens": 0, "outputTokens": 405, "totalTokens": null, "costUsd": null, "tokenAccounting": "provider-cli-native", "invocations": 1 }, "usage": { "inputTokens": 97388, "cachedInputTokens": 72192, "outputTokens": 1235, "totalTokens": null, "costUsd": null, "tokenAccounting": "provider-cli-native", "invocations": 2 }, "latencyMs": 50552 }, "runtime": { "exitCode": 0, "correct": true, "delivered": true, "selected": true, "retrievalAttempted": true, "attested": false, "attestationFailed": false, "deliveryPhase": "adapter-pre-action", "mistakeExecuted": false, "outcomeGrade": { "passed": true, "protectedFilesUnchanged": true, "canonicalSourceChanged": true, "generatedSynchronized": true, "verifierExitCode": 0, "verifierOutput": "verification passed", "sourceHash": "5fe684e5cbcac69214d77b1f94a198811c55a71ee2529f6cf270840022deda46", "generatedHash": "245214c35d7bbfcc764b5d1c8fab218c9ce76cda6e436a2d2f426877d5410d2a" }, "usage": { "inputTokens": 337693, "cachedInputTokens": 321095, "outputTokens": 5127, "totalTokens": 342820, "costUsd": 0.27277350000000006, "tokenAccounting": "provider-cli-native-logical-input", "staticSchemaTokens": 0, "capsuleTokens": 212, "instructionTokens": 271 }, "latencyMs": 64639, "preflightLatencyMs": 137, "consumerMcpExposed": false, "preActionReceipt": { "schemaVersion": "ucr.pre-action-receipt/1", "retrievalAttempted": true, "action": "deliver", "delivered": true, "taskId": "multimodel-codex-claude-code-537b7817cb994766", "sessionId": "consumer-session", "trigger": "task", "budget": 384, "capsuleIds": [ "capsule:b95042748125e8131f7a1f3a" ], "objectIds": [ "failure:8121ff635eebf07f29888e8b" ], "capsuleTokens": 212, "injectionTokens": 271, "staticSchemaTokens": 0, "consumerMcpExposed": false, "exposedTools": [], "injectionChannel": "claude-session-start-hook-additional-context", "deliveryEventId": "019fe96e-b57c-7de5-a978-695fcecc335c", "latencyMs": 137, "receiptHash": "0caf3391bc337a77ff83bd234f8b36a6aaacb5d8febc8793d75f56b470178ded" } }, "eventStreamHash": "c4fccf2c6be8b5c4f7a5d17c58e78d53f9650317379197609e2161119ef147fb", "canonicalEvents": 5, "passed": true, "transcriptPublished": false, "studySequence": null, "schemaVersion": "ucr.evidence-row/2", "runId": "live-multimodel-4713afb92c757e6a", "sequence": 0, "previousHash": "475616c62aa856747b9291d73ce4be39d98df9ea538a35362237ca37218b172f", "rowHash": "3ba7a6f4ff3d03f0c6989e0fde49911fd66750ea69fb1884c650417512a36791" } ], "rowCount": 1, "chainHead": "3ba7a6f4ff3d03f0c6989e0fde49911fd66750ea69fb1884c650417512a36791", "transcriptsPublished": false, "endedAt": "2026-08-10T02:10:43.748Z", "ledgerHash": "e0357f955ac197f9e42665d91cec0b9345d1d8a15a620d25dd9ceb8f0cf4a9a8", "signature": "amTj2i3lo0hkjaGxNrTZJmQ/pHqBxKk2I2X5O7DfsbK+wuNKjf2LEeW8aTYDmtpDglJEGbIBPfs1oCfNQ+kaDQ==" }, "ledgerPublicKey": "-----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY-----\nMCowBQYDK2VwAyEApDtaMuD+Osr364jqA/aui+AIW58szGVpDga52g/Vyu8=\n-----END PUBLIC KEY-----\n", "ledgerVerification": { "valid": true, "diagnostics": [], "validSignature": true, "ledgerHash": "e0357f955ac197f9e42665d91cec0b9345d1d8a15a620d25dd9ceb8f0cf4a9a8", "rowCount": 1 }, "transcriptPublished": false, "passed": true, "limitations": [ "one task per direction is executable coverage, not a powered effectiveness estimate", "mandatory adapter preflight is evaluated here; advisory-only clients require separate evidence and cannot claim guaranteed prevention", "provider aliases require provider response metadata before exact model-version claims", "the installed standalone Gemini CLI and the advertised Copilot Gemini model were unavailable to the authenticated accounts; their failed attempts remain separate negative evidence", "no competitive superiority claim is permitted from this smoke matrix" ], "reportHash": "02cf2f4f593eec9e109a78a125be346dcee1592d7af3d2068ada45bca5eecc28" }