{
  "schema": 1,
  "name": "v1.4.0-writing-host-validation",
  "version": "0.1",
  "aiosVersion": "1.3.2 + v1.4.0-dev commits de53884, ef5404a, and current Codex raw-output follow-up",
  "evaluatedAt": "2026-06-19",
  "dataBoundary": "All sample workspaces are de-identified and synthetic. This file records host runtime evidence status only.",
  "evidencePolicy": "A case can be marked skillRuntimeConfirmed=yes only when the host actually loads and triggers the named aios-* Skill and a raw output file is archived. Prompt paste results are not accepted.",
  "hostChecks": [
    {
      "host": "codex",
      "status": "partial-confirmed",
      "evidence": [
        "Get-Command -All codex found Codex desktop package resources under WindowsApps.",
        "The packaged codex.exe and codex-command-runner.exe still fail from this workspace with Windows access denied.",
        "The global @openai/codex Node entry exists but cannot run because @openai/codex-win32-x64 is missing.",
        "The current Codex desktop thread loaded installed Skill files from C:\\Users\\white\\.codex\\skills and archived two raw writing outputs.",
        "This confirms Codex current-thread Skill behavior, while CLI replay remains unavailable."
      ]
    },
    {
      "host": "workbuddy",
      "status": "confirmed",
      "evidence": [
        "Get-Command workbuddy returned no PATH command.",
        "WorkBuddy desktop is installed at C:\\Users\\white\\AppData\\Local\\Programs\\WorkBuddy\\WorkBuddy.exe.",
        "The bundled non-interactive CLI runs through C:\\Users\\white\\AppData\\Local\\Programs\\WorkBuddy\\resources\\app.asar.unpacked\\cli\\bin\\codebuddy with WorkBuddy's bundled Node.",
        "npm run install:user installed aios-tender-write and aios-scheme-write into the WorkBuddy skills directory.",
        "Two WorkBuddy --print raw outputs were archived under prompts/evaluations/skill-runtime/raw."
      ]
    }
  ],
  "cases": [
    {
      "caseId": "codex-tender-writing-sample",
      "host": "codex",
      "skillId": "aios-tender-write",
      "expectedGateSkill": "aios-commercial-tender",
      "sampleWorkspacePath": "templates/document-writing-samples/tender",
      "triggerPrompt": "$aios-tender-write 请基于该工作台生成或改写 draft.md，并保留交给 aios-commercial-tender 的审核门禁。",
      "skillRuntimeConfirmed": "yes",
      "rawOutputPath": "prompts/evaluations/skill-runtime/raw/codex-tender-writing-sample.md",
      "evidence": [
        "The current Codex desktop thread loaded C:\\Users\\white\\.codex\\skills\\aios-tender-write\\SKILL.md.",
        "The archived raw output includes aios-tender-write and the aios-commercial-tender gate.",
        "Codex CLI replay is still unavailable, so this is current-thread host evidence rather than a standalone CLI transcript."
      ]
    },
    {
      "caseId": "codex-scheme-writing-sample",
      "host": "codex",
      "skillId": "aios-scheme-write",
      "expectedGateSkill": "aios-construction-scheme",
      "sampleWorkspacePath": "templates/document-writing-samples/scheme",
      "triggerPrompt": "$aios-scheme-write 请基于该工作台生成或改写 draft.md，并保留交给 aios-construction-scheme 的审核门禁。",
      "skillRuntimeConfirmed": "yes",
      "rawOutputPath": "prompts/evaluations/skill-runtime/raw/codex-scheme-writing-sample.md",
      "evidence": [
        "The current Codex desktop thread loaded C:\\Users\\white\\.codex\\skills\\aios-scheme-write\\SKILL.md.",
        "The archived raw output includes aios-scheme-write and the aios-construction-scheme gate.",
        "Codex CLI replay is still unavailable, so this is current-thread host evidence rather than a standalone CLI transcript."
      ]
    },
    {
      "caseId": "workbuddy-tender-writing-sample",
      "host": "workbuddy",
      "skillId": "aios-tender-write",
      "expectedGateSkill": "aios-commercial-tender",
      "sampleWorkspacePath": "templates/document-writing-samples/tender",
      "triggerPrompt": "$aios-tender-write 请基于该工作台生成或改写 draft.md，并保留交给 aios-commercial-tender 的审核门禁。",
      "skillRuntimeConfirmed": "yes",
      "rawOutputPath": "prompts/evaluations/skill-runtime/raw/workbuddy-tender-writing-sample.md",
      "evidence": [
        "WorkBuddy bundled CodeBuddy CLI version 2.103.3 ran with --print --output-format text.",
        "The archived raw output includes aios-tender-write and the aios-commercial-tender gate.",
        "The prompt required no file modifications and the output states that no files were modified."
      ]
    },
    {
      "caseId": "workbuddy-scheme-writing-sample",
      "host": "workbuddy",
      "skillId": "aios-scheme-write",
      "expectedGateSkill": "aios-construction-scheme",
      "sampleWorkspacePath": "templates/document-writing-samples/scheme",
      "triggerPrompt": "$aios-scheme-write 请基于该工作台生成或改写 draft.md，并保留交给 aios-construction-scheme 的审核门禁。",
      "skillRuntimeConfirmed": "yes",
      "rawOutputPath": "prompts/evaluations/skill-runtime/raw/workbuddy-scheme-writing-sample.md",
      "evidence": [
        "WorkBuddy bundled CodeBuddy CLI version 2.103.3 ran with --print --output-format text.",
        "The archived raw output includes aios-scheme-write and the aios-construction-scheme gate.",
        "The prompt required no file modifications and the output states that no files were modified."
      ]
    }
  ],
  "scorecardReview": {
    "status": "passed",
    "scorecardPath": "prompts/evaluations/engineering-document-writing-scorecard.json",
    "reviewPath": "prompts/evaluations/skill-runtime/v1.4.0-writing-host-scorecard-review.md",
    "reviewedCases": [
      "codex-tender-writing-sample",
      "codex-scheme-writing-sample",
      "workbuddy-tender-writing-sample",
      "workbuddy-scheme-writing-sample"
    ],
    "notAClaim": "The review proves pilot-readiness evidence quality, not customer-ready final document quality."
  },
  "releaseGate": {
    "status": "evidence-ready",
    "notReadyUntil": "The release metadata is bumped to 1.4.0, all version sync points are updated, the full release validation bundle passes on the final release commit, and v1.4.0 is tagged and published.",
    "notAClaim": "Raw host evidence is ready for release preparation; it is not itself a published v1.4.0 release."
  }
}