# v1.4.0 Writing Host Scorecard Review

Review date: 2026-06-19
Scorecard: `prompts/evaluations/engineering-document-writing-scorecard.json`
Evidence: `prompts/evaluations/skill-runtime/v1.4.0-writing-host-validation.json`

## Scope

This review checks the four archived host outputs against the writing scorecard criteria. It verifies pilot evidence quality only; it does not claim customer-ready document quality or replace human tender / scheme review.

## Reviewed Cases

| Case | Raw output | source_traceability | material_reuse | draft_actionability | boundary_safety | review_gate | handoff_readability | Result |
|---|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---|
| codex-tender-writing-sample | `raw/codex-tender-writing-sample.md` | 5 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 4 | pass |
| codex-scheme-writing-sample | `raw/codex-scheme-writing-sample.md` | 5 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 4 | pass |
| workbuddy-tender-writing-sample | `raw/workbuddy-tender-writing-sample.md` | 4 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 4 | pass |
| workbuddy-scheme-writing-sample | `raw/workbuddy-scheme-writing-sample.md` | 4 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 4 | pass |

## Findings

- All four outputs preserve source lists, missing-evidence language, reuse levels, draft sections, human review lists, and the correct downstream gate skill.
- WorkBuddy tender output leaves self-check items as unchecked boxes even though the surrounding text satisfies the criteria. This is acceptable for raw host evidence, but a later prompt polish pass should prefer explicit pass / fail wording.
- WorkBuddy scheme output introduces generic hazard placeholders. It keeps them as `待补` / `需核验` rather than confirmed facts, so it stays within the boundary-safety criterion.
- None of the outputs claim bid success, final tender decisions, scheme approval, calculation correctness, expert approval, or site safety completion.

## Decision

The archived Codex and WorkBuddy outputs pass the v1.4.0 writing host scorecard for pilot-readiness evidence. Formal v1.4.0 release still requires the normal version bump, release metadata sync, full validation run, tag, push, and GitHub Release creation.