# Gen-Review Scorecard, worked examples

The schema itself lives in SKILL.md's own "The Gen-Review Scorecard" section;
these are worked examples of it filled in.

## A FAILING prompt (score below floor AND overflow)

```text
Gen-Review Scorecard
cycle:            3
prompt:           billing-summary-with-filters
rubricScore:      88/105, below-floor (Excellence needs ≥92)
overflow:         fail, 2 overflowElements (table-ui bleeds past the card edge)
cosmeticFindings: P1 1 (the overflow, auto-counted) · P2 0 · P3 1 (icon misalignment in header)
causeCode:        WRONG_CHUNK, routed to a2ui-maintenance
renderStatus:     ok
verdict:          FAILING, score below floor AND overflow present (independent gates; either alone fails the prompt)
refs:             corpus chunk `billing-summary-filters-01`; review/cycle-3/decomposed/billing-summary-with-filters.json
```

## A RENDER_FAILURE prompt

Phases 2–4 never ran, so their fields are legally UNMEASURED rather than blank:

```text
Gen-Review Scorecard
cycle:            3
prompt:           claims-timeline-with-attachments
rubricScore:      UNMEASURED, no render to score (RENDER_FAILURE)
overflow:         UNMEASURED, no screenshot produced
cosmeticFindings: UNMEASURED, no screenshot produced
causeCode:        TRANSPILER_GAP, routed to primitive-authoring
renderStatus:     RENDER_FAILURE, decompose script timed out after 30s, canvas never painted
verdict:          FAILING, RENDER_FAILURE blocks the exit gate regardless of any other field
refs:             n/a, no decomposed JSON produced; partial capture at review/cycle-3/raw-dom/claims-timeline-with-attachments
```